How to think about the decision: repair vs. replace
There's only one correct question when a MacBook breaks: how much does the repair cost relative to how much the device is worth? Not how much it cost when you bought it, but how much it's worth now on the second-hand market.
The mistake many people make is comparing the repair cost to the price of a new MacBook. A MacBook Air M1 from 2020 doesn't cost 6,000 RON to replace — you can find a refurbished one in excellent condition for 2,800–3,200 RON. The right reference is the secondary market.
💡 The base formula
Ratio = Repair cost ÷ Second-hand MacBook value × 100
If the ratio is small → repair. If it's large → think about replacement.
A second important factor: the MacBook's age and overall condition. A 6-year-old device that's had liquid contact, has a degraded battery and a partially non-functional keyboard isn't worth an expensive repair even if the ratio seems acceptable. A 3-year-old MacBook in perfect condition, with a single defect, is a completely different situation.
The three decision thresholds
Based on experience with thousands of customers, we've defined three clear zones:
| Repair / value ratio | Verdict |
|---|---|
| ✅ Under 30% | Repair without doubt |
| 🤔 30–55% | Worth it, with conditions |
| ⚠️ Over 55% | Think carefully |
⚠️ Important
Thresholds are indicative, not absolute. A repair at 60% of value can be justified if the MacBook is otherwise pristine or has a rare config (large RAM, large SSD). The financial calculation is the starting point — the final decision is still yours.
Concrete examples for popular models
Real scenarios with current service prices and estimated second-hand values for the Romanian market:
MacBook Air Intel 2013–2017 (A1466)
MacBook Air M1 2020
MacBook Pro 13" Intel 2016–2019
MacBook Pro 14" M1 2021
MacBook Air M3 2024 13"
MacBook Pro 15" 2016–2017
Newer MacBooks (M1, M2, M3) hold high second-hand value, so repairs are almost always justified. Older Intel MacBooks have low value — expensive repairs (display, logic board) rarely make financial sense.